The Epidemic of Categorical Sameness

A customer visits three websites looking for a local service. Each business promises professional work, exceptional service and a team the customer can trust. The words are polished. The claims may all be true. And after reading all three, the customer still has no clear reason to remember one business over another.

I call that categorical sameness: when businesses in the same industry rely on the same generic claims and language, making their real differences difficult for customers to see.

Categorical sameness has been with us for a long time. Businesses have borrowed the language of their industries for years, sanding down their own perspectives until they sound like everyone else. Now AI can produce more of that same copy in seconds. We’re taking an old problem and giving it a production line.

That should bother you. A business can do excellent work, hold itself to a higher standard and care deeply about its customers—and still present itself as interchangeable with the business down the street.

What does categorical sameness look like?

Categorical sameness often starts with a sentence that sounds perfectly reasonable.

“A team you can trust.”
“Quality work at an affordable price.”
“Solutions tailored to your needs.”

I’m not suggesting those claims are false. I’m asking what a customer can do with them. If every business says it’s trustworthy, the word gives the customer very little help deciding whom to call.

The same is true of “quality.” A business owner may have a clear standard in mind: how a job is assessed, how the work is checked, or what happens when something goes wrong. But the word quality doesn’t communicate those details on its own. It asks the customer to take the business at its word.

A useful question is: What does that claim look like in practice? If you say you communicate well, explain how customers receive updates. If you say you have a careful process, describe a part of that process that helps the customer make a decision. Only make claims you can support and actually deliver.

Why has categorical sameness become an epidemic?

Generic marketing language existed long before AI could write a sentence. Businesses have always looked at competitors, borrowed familiar phrases and tried to sound like an established company in their industry.

The difference now is how quickly we can make more of it. A business owner can ask AI for a homepage, service descriptions and a month of content in the time it once took to get a first draft moving. That speed is useful. But speed doesn’t correct a weak starting point; it gives that starting point more places to appear.

That’s why I call categorical sameness an epidemic. We’ve made it easy to publish words that sound finished before we’ve decided what those words need to say. Give AI a generic description of your business, accept its polished draft, and you can put more interchangeable language into the world without ever noticing what’s missing.

Meanwhile, the business down the street can follow the same process. The copy may not be identical, but the effect can be the same: two different businesses describing themselves with the same safe claims. The customer sees a category, not a choice.

Why does AI-generated copy so often sound like everyone else?

A general-purpose AI tool can write quickly, but it doesn’t automatically know your business’s position, voice or standards.

That matters because most business owners aren’t professional writers. They know their work. They know the questions customers ask and the decisions that go into doing a job well. Turning all of that into website copy takes time and a different set of skills. Asking AI for help is a reasonable response.

Illustrative example: An HVAC owner asks an AI tool to write an “About Us” section for a local company that provides reliable service. The draft comes back with sentences about experienced technicians, customer satisfaction and dependable solutions. It reads smoothly. A competing HVAC company could provide a similar prompt and receive many of the same ideas.

Neither owner has done anything wrong by asking for help. But neither draft has much information about what the company actually believes, how it works, or what a customer can expect.

AI can assist with research, organize information and produce a useful first draft. Research still needs verification, and the writing needs context. Give the tool:

  • Your approved voice guidance
  • The services you actually provide
  • Your standards for doing the work
  • Answers to real customer questions
  • Then review its work for accuracy and for the perspective only you can supply.

We’ve written more about how to use AI for marketing without sounding like everyone else. The principle is simple: AI can help with the writing, but someone has to take responsibility for what the writing says.

Use AI. Remain human.

How can categorical sameness make a business invisible?

Categorical sameness makes a business invisible in two ways. It can leave the business without a useful answer to a specific question, making it harder to surface for that need. And even when the business does appear, it can give the customer so little to distinguish it that the opportunity passes without making an impression.

Imagine a homeowner asking which local company repairs a particular type of system. A page that clearly describes the work a business performs gives that person more useful information than a page that says only “we provide quality solutions.” Specificity doesn’t guarantee a ranking, but a relevant answer gives both the reader and the search system more to work with.

Search itself is changing, too. Google says its AI search features can handle complex questions and may perform multiple related searches when developing a response. Its guidance also says existing search engine optimization practices still apply; keywords and technical fundamentals haven’t disappeared.

The question a customer asks, their location and the search experience they use can affect what they see. Google explains that search results can differ based on context and personalization. That doesn’t mean every person receives a completely unique result. It does mean a single broad phrase on your homepage may not answer the more specific questions customers bring to search.

There’s no promise that a detailed page will appear for every relevant question. Google explicitly says that following its guidance doesn’t guarantee a page will be indexed or shown. But a page that never explains the work, the customer’s problem or the conditions around the service leaves those answers unavailable to anyone who might need them.

What happens when everyone can publish more?

More content gives a business more chances to be seen. Categorical sameness gives it more chances to sound like everybody else.

A polished article can look productive while saying nothing a customer couldn’t have found on a competitor’s website. A popular post can bring attention from people who have no reason to become customers. There’s nothing inherently wrong with reaching a broad audience, but attention alone doesn’t explain what your business stands for or why someone should trust it.

That’s where relevance matters. A useful piece of content connects a question your customer actually has to an answer your business is equipped to give. It doesn’t need to appeal to everyone. It needs to be worth the attention of the people you’re trying to serve.

Google’s people-first content guidance asks site owners to consider their intended audience, first-hand expertise and the value a reader gets from a page. That’s guidance for creating helpful content, not a formula that guarantees trust or placement.

How can you tell if your business sounds like everyone else?

Categorical sameness is easiest to spot when you take away the visual identity that’s doing the distinguishing for you.

Remove your name, logo and colors from a page and read the words on their own. Could that copy sit comfortably on a competitor’s website? If it could, your business may be relying on its appearance to communicate differences that its words never explain.

Read each claim and ask:

  • Could a competitor say the same thing?
  • What does this claim look like in the way we actually work?
  • What can a customer see that supports it?

Then check the page from the customer’s side. Does it answer a question they came with, or does it ask them to admire the company before they know if the company can help?

That distinction connects to a point I made in “No One Cares About What You Do”: your experience and standards matter, but customers first need to understand how you can help with their problem. Your difference has to be relevant to them.

A distinctive sentence is only useful if it’s true. Don’t invent a process to sound different, and don’t make a promise your team can’t keep. If your strongest claims are common across your industry, that’s a reason to look more closely at how you do the work and what customers need to understand about it.

What should a business do instead?

Consistent, relevant, on-brand content gives a business a better standard than simply asking whether a draft sounds professional.

Don’t chase attention. Do be consistent.
Consistency means a customer can recognize the same business over time. Your website shouldn’t promise one experience while your sales conversation describes another. It also means showing up at a pace you can sustain rather than publishing in a rush and disappearing for months.

Don’t copy trends. Do be relevant.
A trend may give you an idea, but the customer’s question should determine whether that idea belongs in your content. If a subject has no connection to the work you do or the people you serve, attention alone may not make it useful.

Don’t sound professional. Do be on-brand.
I’m not suggesting your writing should be careless. I’m suggesting that “professional” is a low bar if all it means is polished, safe and interchangeable. On-brand writing should sound like your business and reflect what you actually believe. It should also be clear enough for a customer to understand without translating a paragraph of industry language.

You get to choose what you say and when you want to say it. But you don’t get to choose when your ideal customer needs you.

The aim is to give someone a useful, recognizable answer when that need arrives. That takes more thought than asking AI for another batch of posts, but it doesn’t require you to become a full-time writer.

Who should do the thinking when AI does the writing?

The business owner remains responsible for the perspective behind the content, even when AI helps produce the words.

You are the head. AI is the hands.

Start with one sentence on your website that any competitor could have written. Ask what you actually mean by it, then replace the generic claim with a specific explanation you can stand behind. Categorical sameness grows every time a business publishes the safe version of what it could have said. Your business has a choice about the next sentence.

If you’d like help assessing the foundation behind your content, contact ElectroDash for a conversation.

share on facebook
share on linkedin
share on x
Picture of Daniel Canvas
Daniel Canvas